The Rory Gilmore Reading List is a LIE

(she didn't even read all of them)

the Rory Gilmore reading list is a lie

I think we are all familiar with the Rory Gilmore Reading List (and if you’re not, check it out here). It is a list of four-hundred and eight books many people like to pretend to have read. No one has actually read the entire list. Not even Rory Gilmore. That’s right, the Rory Gilmore reading list is a lie. Or maybe it’s a conspiracy designed to get millennial women to actually read Yoga for Dummies (yes, that is on the list). Either way, it’s still not a list of the books Rory reads in the series.

The Rory Gilmore Reading List is just a list of every single book mentioned in the show. And while I applaud the dedication of the person who sat there and put this together, there’s some false advertising going on here. Sure, some of them are books that Rory is actually seen reading or talks about having read. Any real fan knows Rory was reading Dead Souls when her application for Harvard came in the mail (wink wink). And that she got Dean to read Pride and Prejudice. But…

not even Rory has read every book on this list

A significant number of the books on this list are not actually books Rory actually reads. Or has mentioned reading or is even seen carrying around. Case in point: Tuesdays with Morrie and Who Moved My Cheese?

If you’re familiar with Gilmore Girls and thought these books are an odd addition to the list, you’re not alone. I’ll admit I’m not the most attentive TV show audience. I usually have it on in the background, especially when it’s a show I’ve watched as many times as Gilmore Girls. So I just assumed it was sitting on a random side table in the Gilmore house at one point. But no. It’s worse. These two books were mentioned. In the scene where Lorelei and Rory visit Harvard and Rory is stressing out about how she’ll never read all the books in the nineteen libraries (relatable). And Lorelei says this: 

“But honey, you don’t have to read every one of them. Tuesdays with Morrie? Skip that. Who Moved My Cheese? Just stuff you already know.”

They are literally on the list because they were mentioned as books to not read. Again, nothing against the person who spent what was probably an absurd about of time compiling the list… but I don’t think those books should be on it. Or they should have called it “Every Book Mentioned on Gilmore Girls.” Which is what this list actually is. Although, that does bring us to another issue…

“excuse me. book or movie?”

Okay, they are books. But the reason some of them made it onto the list is not because someone on the show made a reference to the book. We all know that every single time Lorelei references The Godfather, she’s taking about the movie. And yet, Mario Puzo’s book made the list.

I’m willing to bet not a single character read Babe or Bambi (neither of which I was aware were books. And any references to Freaky Friday were most definitely about the book. Sorry, Mary Rodgers. And Rosemary’s Baby? It wouldn’t shock me if someone had read it, but that one is definitely a movie reference (click here for proof).

If you’ve watched Gilmore Girls, you are aware that Rory’s book consumption is only rivaled by the Gilmores’ obsession with movies. So I think a lot of the books on this list are really their movie adaptations being mentioned. And I don’t think that merits a spot on the reading list that so many Gilmore fans have been pouring over for years. What do you think?

a lot of this reading list belongs to other characters

Rory is not the only reader in Stars Hollow. Or even in her family. The only person on that show to have read The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire was Richard Gilmore. And it takes him thirty-six years to do it. Most of the other characters on the show who do read have not been alive that long. Also, no one else is interested. I have a degree in history, and even I have no interest in reading it. It’s nearly four-thousand pages (you read that right), and I have other things to read.

Emily also contributes to the list. She mentions her book club reading The Lovely Bones by Alice Sebold and The Crimson Petal and the White by Michael Faber.

Notably, a decent part of the Rory Gilmore reading list actually belongs to Jess Mariano. We know Jess was a big reader, and fans of the series should easily be able to spot which books can be attributed to Jess. Basically all the Ginsburg, Kerouac, Bukowski, or Thompson. (Dean is also a Thompson fan, at one point, he recommends Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas to Rory. Is it just me, or does that not seem like her kind of book?) Rory may have read Howl or On the Road, but those are clearly Jess books. There is definitely some overlap with Rory and Jess’s lists, but they didn’t read all of the same books, so they shouldn’t count. Right?

Also, since the list was updated after A Year in the Life, we know that Cheryl Strayed’s Wild is not a Rory book, but a Lorelei book. According to another deep dive list I came across, a few other books on the list also belong to Lorelei (not including the books that were added to the list because of references she makes). Lorelei is spotted reading Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting by in America by Barbara Ehrenreich and I’m with the Band by Pamela Des Barres.

But the most egregious thing that makes this list a lie…

the list makes some gargantuan leaps

We have established that not all of the books on this belong to Rory’s personal reading canon. Or are even books in the context of how they’re mentioned on the show. But a few of them are never even mentioned or referred to at all. One in particular came to mind while I was (yet again) perusing the list: Helter Skelter by Vincent Bugliosi.

First of all, a true crime book about the Manson murders seems much more of a Lorelei than a Rory thing. So that alone would probably mean it shouldn’t be on this list at all. But I thought it was a little weird that the book was specifically mentioned. And I was correct.

According to this website, which very helpfully connects all the Gilmore Girls cultural references with the episodes to which they belong, the Helter Skelter references happens in episode twelve of season two. I just so happen to remember exactly where this “reference” occurred. Richard is criticizing Lorelei for how lenient he thinks she is with Rory. And she responds: “Rory’s my kid and I make the rules, so if she comes home one day and says, ‘Hey, uh, I’m gonna spend the weekend with Patricia Krenwinkel’ I say, ‘Okay, grab a sweater,’ you just have to deal.” (Patricia Krenwinkel was one of the Manson followers who was involved in the murder spree, in case you are not familiar.)

Call me crazy, but that is not even remotely a reference to a specific book. It is referring to a well-known cultural event, about which several books have been written. Helter Skelter just happens to be one of them. But I’m gonna call bullshit on this one, sorry. Take it off the list!

(Note: I have actually read it and really liked it. It was my first foray into true crime, and I think it was a good one. So nothing against the book, but it does not remotely belong on the Rory Gilmore Reading List.)

I am now having a crazy impulse to go through the entire list and validate exactly how they got there and whether they actually belong. I don’t have time for this.

what’s in a name?

Another book that was included on the list for a weird movie-related reason is Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier. Now, this book does not seem that out of place to me. I can absolutely see Rory reading this one. But there’s no evidence of her doing so. There is, however, (rather subtle) proof that she watched the Hitchcock adaptation. A blogger lays the whole thing out here if you want to read it. But I’ll summarize for this post.

At one point Max (her teacher, who is dating her mother) suggests they use code names outside of school, since Rory is uncomfortable calling him by his first name. He decides to call Rory “Rebecca.” Now, if you haven’t read Rebecca, the titular character is the dead wife of a man name Max. Which makes this kind of a weird suggestion if you have that story in mind, but whatever. Rory then suggests “Norman” as her code name for Max, claiming Psycho was on earlier. Another Hitchcock film. When Max isn’t excited about “Norman,” Rory offers “Alfred” instead. So there is a bit of a Hitchcock connection there. Maybe a stretch, but seems possible.

But names associated with specific books also resulted in those books being on the list. Lorelei naming Rory’s school project chick Stella, just so she could scream out “Stella!” when it went missing doesn’t mean either of them have read A Streetcar Named Desire. Let’s be honest, it probably just means she’s watched the Marlon Brando adaptation. The play itself is never seen nor mentioned by name.

posters, especially in the early aughts, didn’t equate to reading the book

The naughties – which is apparently another name that decade goes by – were a time of posters. A lot of posters. Fellow millennials can back me up here… sometimes you put up posters for show. They were a way to look cool and intellectual (or punk or emo or whatever you wanted) before social media. Yes, that time existed. If I had a poster of Tolstoy on my wall, it didn’t necessarily mean I read War and Peace. It might have just meant that I wanted people to think I had. Or I was being “ironic” because we thought that’s what that word meant for some reason.

Anyway, whoever put this list together seemed to use posters towards the reading list. Take, for example, Michael Moore’s Fahrenheit 9/11. If you were alive when the show originally aired, you will remember the posters for that movie plastered everywhere. Including Lane’s bedroom AND Rory’s college bedroom in the apartment she shared with Paris (photo evidence here). Call me crazy, but I don’t think movie posters count towards a reading list.

Posters not even belonging to Rory ended up on this list, too. Like Marty’s poster of A Confederacy of Dunces. Which, to be fair, is actually a book and not a movie or an author. But it’s not even in Rory’s room. This is not Marty’s reading list. (We should also note that Jess is spotted actually reading this book earlier in the series, but we never see this book mentioned by Rory.)

Either way, I’d like to petition to take all the “books” that are really just random background posters off the list. They don’t count and you can’t convince me otherwise.

pop culture doesn’t always come from books

Like Helter Skelter, there seem to be a few books on the list that are on the list simply because they relate to some element of pop culture, or even an idiom. One that immediately stood out to me: George W. Bushisms : The Slate Book of The Accidental Wit and Wisdom of our 43rd President by Jacob Weisberg. (Side note: I’m pretty sure I owned this book at some point, and I have no idea who gave it to me. I was twelve when it came out.) I’m pretty sure this one is just a result of the three times the show trolled President Bush (who was president when the show started airing). Notably, Lorelei saying, “I hate president Bush. He’s stupid and his face is too tiny for his head and I just want to toss him out.” Amusing, but not a book reference.

I think the aforementioned Fahrenheit 9/11 and Helter Skelter also fit into the pop culture leaps. I think we can also put Jurassic Park here, though even that’s a stretch since neither the book or (more believably) the movie is not mentioned at all during the series. Lorelei simply makes a quip that she wants to read Proust to she can say “as Marcel Proust would say…” since “as Michael Crichton would say…” isn’t the same. That is apparently enough to land Jurassic Park on the list. It’s not even close to the only book Crichton wrote, or had written when that episode aired.

It would not surprise me in the slightest if there were more books like this on the list. There are a ton of pop culture references in the show. And while some of them do reference books, they’re few and far between. Miss Patty making her dance class girls walk around with Harry Potter books on their heads does not earn them a spot on Rory’s reading list. And someone using the phrase “hell hath no fury like a woman scorned,” does not mean they’ve read The Mourning Bride by William Congreve. Considering that character is Louise, I’d bet she hasn’t. I hadn’t even heard of that book until just now. The phrase is much more well-known than the book. I bet you’ve heard that phrase, even if you didn’t know what it was from (like me).

it’s not Rory Gilmore’s Reading List, not sorry

The Rory Gilmore Reading List is honestly kind of a mess. I’d say it’s a list of books mentioned in the series as a whole, but even that’s a bit iffy. Again, no shade to the person who put it together – because I can only imagine how long that took – but I don’t think it’s accurate. And it annoys me a little bit that, for years, people have been attempting to read the whole list when there’s proof Rory herself didn’t read a good number of these books.

I’m honestly tempted at this point to go through and make my own list, but my attention span would absolutely not let me do that. I also have books to read and blog posts to write and a whole full-time job to do, so that’s just not going to happen. If any of you want to create an accurate Rory Gilmore Reading List, please let me know! This one just isn’t it. And if you have read Who Moved My Cheese? in an effort to complete this list, I’m sorry. You should have listened to Lorelei on that one (probably, I haven’t read it so I don’t know if it’s any good or not).

let’s read like Rory, instead of reading everything she’s read

For now, I just want to say: you don’t have to read this entire list. In fact, don’t. Lorelei Gilmore herself says some of these books are not worth reading. If anything, just assume they all watched the movie versions and do that. It’s much more plausible than the chaotic mashup that is the “official” list.

There is no doubt that Rory is extremely well-read. So if you’re a fan who wants to read like Rory, I say try and capture the spirit of her reading instead of trying to read this list. She read a lot of classics and nonfiction (biographies in particular), but also some of the popular books of the time. She was up to date on books as well as pop culture and world news. She read widely, but also kind of did her own thing. She picked up books no one else was reading as well as books everyone has read (or says they have).


I hope you enjoyed this post! I was not expecting to fall down a rabbit hole once I started writing this, but I had fun with it. I’d love to hear what you think! Are you a Gilmore Girls fan? Have you attempted the Rory Gilmore Reading List Challenge?

If you’re curious, I did a post earlier this year about which books I think Rory would be reading now. Click here for a Rory Gilmore reading list that makes more sense (at least I think so).

And check out my bookshop, where you can buy books and also shop my curated collections of my personal favorites AND all of the books I’ve read for my reading eperiments. Or you can just buy whatever books you want to. I get a small commission at no extra cost to you, and you get to support your choice of indie bookstores – it’s a win all around!

Click here if you want to check out my bookshop and support this blog!

share:
Follow adventures of a bibliophile on WordPress.com

recent posts

4 Responses

  1. You were so freaking thorough for this post and I’m living for it. When I was younger, people said I was most like Rory, in that I had books with me everywhere (hopefully not so much on the selfishness scale), but I definitely haven’t read even a fraction of the books listed. I never thought about what all made it onto this list and how much of it was taken from the oddest and briefest conversations on the show or moments that didn’t even have anything to do with her. Very illuminating!

    1. I am so tempted to rewatch and make an actual list of JUST the books Rory reads or has talked about reading. But I do still need to sleep, unfortunately ?

  2. I’m here from a very specific Google search, wishing I wasnt a quarter of the way through a re-watch lol! Maybe I will try to do it on the next one though…

    I have even wondered if an AI could make a database of all the pop culture references, books and otherwise!

Leave a Reply